Having a great ground game is wonderful, but if you can’t get the guy to follow you then it’s worthless. Ep11. they time and again tell these experienced warriors what is effective in combat; despite not one of them having seen any. Ep7. Besides, it looks good!”, In reality, assuming that they actually do some sort of simulation, it’s probably on a bigger server, and he’s (at best) going in via telnet or SSH or some other method of connecting. Enter the Monte Carlo algorithm. 24 Votes in Poll. OK. Quite simple… Spartan vs Ninja… They don’t mention the ninja tactics of kill without being seen… using poisons, or even patience. variables mid simulation at random times. A SPARTAN vs. A NINJA. It’s TV science, and for its part, it at least makes SOME people think. (If we knew the answer to that question, there would be no need for a simulation.) Self care and ideas to help you live a healthier, happier life. Who would win in a fight, X or Y? Also, Blue Mode destroys Green Mode. If they atleast TRIED in the least to use some historical factors as to what actually MADE them deadly.. it’d be more interesting… and the whole “gladiator” episode wtf??? Instead of pitting two groups of one thousand warriors against each other in one giant battle, the software matches up two single warriors—an archetypal ninja and Spartan, or samurai and Viking raider—for one thousand consecutive matches. Only that they failed to convince me of anything except their own bias. MIT vs Cal Tech (had to throw the geeks in there). Someone slips; an arm gets hit hard enough to make it useless; the shield breaks; something. Even if we can time travel and pluck a few of these guys and toss them in an octagon, the results probably won’t be consistent.. it’s just not that hard to plug human spirit into a block of C++ code :p, ep 2 – viking vs samurai. It’s meant to promote the video game. If there was a spartan with a gun, he’d be a freaking God. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetsuro_Shigematsu Do you actually know how a samurai would fight. And Sans' advantages are large ones, while Undyne's are surmountable, which was ultimately her downfall. Cavalry presumably move faster than elephants, but are less powerful against a lone soldier; archers can attack safely from longer distances, but are handicapped by forest terrain; and so on. I also want to mention that when they actually said that powdered glass in the eyes would only slow a spartan down, I almost bust a gut laughing. It’s clear that a knight would beat a pirate and knights had pistols too later on, I don’t even know what time frame it is for either of them when pirates, When knights? (anyone under 30 needs to do some 80’s research to understand that joke!) The x-factors were not as prominent in the first season. Theoretically, the Monte Carlo method might compensate for the programmers’ inability to identify the single most important factor in these warriors’ battle. Welcome to the TABS (Totally Accurate Battle Simulator) community on Game Jolt! Ep10. I have no clue about any specific encounter without real factors being involved. I’m not saying there isn’t a kernel of truth; they obviously put some effort into testing the weaponry. Here we compare both Rhino vs Hippo characteristics and know who going to win the fight. I hold the same attitude towards kung fu movies, UFC and MMA.. they are there for a reason, folks doing it are great athletes and guys love watching or even training in it to stroke off our inner bad ass alter ego.. but for deeper martial and personal development I look elsewhere in traditional arts.. everything has it’s place in this world, what matter is their place and meaning to you personally and I suppose. Because i’ve been learning histery and i have never herd of a viking who throws away a weapen or a sheld. It’s more or less weapon comparisons. They used the halberd (naginata) where they should have used the spear. A 2h sword is no match against a shield, and in the Centurian vs. Rajput episode, they completely ignored the fact the shield was there. Wow, some people actually take this show seriously? from a random number generator (dice). NAME STEALER! What if the mob got a batch of bad ammo and one of the yazuka dudes ate an incorrectly prepared bloatfish? On season three a new level has been added, and a new program that take into account more info on the warrior himself not oly his weapons. I Love mathematics and a professor of mine once gave a perfect example of how dumb computers are. The whole thing is interesting to a point but I can’t see past the ingrained cynicism of the show creators and their desire for ratings. Other than the fact that we don’t have all the hard data, there are just way too many variables.. what if it’s a constipated ninja vs a depressed spartan? Thank you, that’s all for now <3 I also love this blog post. The samurai PROVED he could shoot out an opponent’s eyes with relative ease. Tell me if they had the Samurai lose because of that Kanabo he never used ,what would the Japanfiles done screamed they dint even use it after they took time to look up the actual Samurai. A monte Carlo simulation can’t ever tell you if something will happen. So when the battle simulator says “gumbi defeats barny 650 times” you can think of it this way: if we know nothing about gumbi, and nothing about barny, we can expect gumbi to win a fight … The examples you cited making a sandwich was used by me when teaching ppl programming. It’s a silly debate over a Spike TV program, I’m well aware as I’m sure most everyone else involved is aware. What? . ... Idk we will have to wait and see. The UFC was not to prove who was better, It was an infomercial to advertise the Gracie name. If you don’t want to discuss dork topics or feel that the topic is intellectually beneath you, then please move on without the name-calling or telling me to relax. Thrand also says that our ancestors fought to be remembered in the saga’s and immortalized, where now they will be more likely remembered as the school bully. Within that context the show is entertaining I suppose, but not to be taken seriously within any other context such as scientific research. From the ‘O_O’, you could tell that I’m at a young age, but i think it’s comforting to have answers to unknown things. Should we move on to the Batman Vs. Spiderman debate? Dan, “No, but I’m sure I can do something custom” And why would they compare a spartan spear with powdered glass in the eyes? Search, watch, and cook every single Tasty recipe and video ever - all in one place! It seems like a cool idea and maybe interesting to read some of the data but I would not expect anything close to a perfect simulation. even if it wasnt determined by simulator a spartan just is better.the first ever deadliest warrior i saw was mafia vs. yakuza. It’s a truism that those who can do, and those who can’t brag about how good they are at it. For example lets do a little math: Additionally we love BS entertainment as much as anyone, I’m a big Bullshit and Mythbusters fan, however we like it when it isn’t passed off as science. (edited by Blazingsun733) 0. Those other two are normal dudes in costumes, Superman is from another planet, duh…. Unlocking human potential through martial arts. Though, theoretically. Chris, you are taking this show entirely too seriously as one of the commenters from your previous post said, if you are watching this show with a serious meter above 2, you are doing it wrong, lol… I have to admit this show is a guilty pleasure of mine, and it’s got the perfect formula to provide mental masturbation to satisfied the cavemen in all of us (much like everything on Spike TV).. you have to realize, folks who come up with these shows are media rating experts, they know what make the average male tick.. Yandere-Chan vs. Megami Shiromi vs. Megami Aoi vs. Megami Osoro vs. Megami Budo vs. Megami Raibaru vs. Megami Miyuki vs. Megami Rival-chan vs. Megami Use the weapon that THEY would have, meaning bronze. Discover unique things to do, places to eat, and sights to see in the best destinations around the world with Bring Me! Would the endless debates over the ultimate fighting style finally be put to rest, by indisputable scientific evidence? The heyday of the Samurai was several hundred years forward in time. amzn_assoc_fallback_mode = {"type":"search","value":"martial arts"}; For close range weaponry they looked at the different swords. Impressive shot but could he pull that off on a charging and weaving target? Or are you so desperate to hear Max Geiger say “The Viking wins” that you’re willing to embark on such a childish crusade? I have to agree to with Thomas Tan’s comments, it makes perfect sense. Ireland, Afghanistan and Iraq all deserve their Independence, nobody who fights for such a thing on the soil of their fathers fathers father is a terrorist, they are called patriots. Certain forms of war making are simply superior. This is a Proof of Concept for a future project. Depth of cuts is not what prevails in combat; the object does not have to be to kill, it is to remove the combatant from the battle. 0 comments. Viking vs. Samurai I found proof he is a real samurai expert!!! Ninjas aren’t information gatherers. hide. I’d like to see ANYONE fight with two eyes full of glass. THIS IS A BLOG. Colorado’s major bases fell quickly since Colorado enjoys the smallest force to fight back the Texans, but they adapted an unconventional warfare stance that kept the Texans on edge for months. LF Cat et al, software engineering is my profession, martial arts is my hobby, I have pondered this exact project for many years, and I am entitled to take it seriously! The computer then runs a series of test cases, using random numbers that fall within those ranges. It could also help you understand which factors are the most important in terms of fight outcome (this is called a sensitivity analysis). Now imagine this stuff changing itself based on natural selection, we kind’a went beyond “If Then” don’t you think so? at which point the Viking had evolved into the fully armored knight. Tim Henriques December 28, 2019 at 12:02 pm. Or by a panel of judges that uses common sense to adjudicate the simulator results? i my-self watch the “Deadliest” warrior mainly because i would like to build myself weapons from the areas they have in them. 3 - 1 Sanic. Shaolin are monks, Maori are warriors. Because of this static interaction there is no way that a computer can hope to incorporate ingenuity, adaptability, survival or will (all skills used to survive in combat) into a simulation. WITH GRENADEZZZZ!!! If Chuck Liddel had delivered the knife to Caesar’s chest, would Caesar have been able too deliver the immortal question, “i tu Bruti?”. I know this is old, but it’s the internet so I’ll throw my opinion in. Consider the simple act of making a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. taking into consideration but only with the weapons tested. I don’t agree that a tiger would beat a grizzly in a fight, and after a quick google search it seems most people think the grizzly would win (although it would be much closer than a gorrila vs a grizzly fight) Jack Cooper. mettaton simulator- fan made undertale. As long as it takes to get that sword going, the Centurian would of already shield bashed the Rajput in the face, and if he was still swinging after that, the shield would still have enough time to get into block position. Poor Max Geiger’s been canned for a game designer, but life goes on… As for who is the deadliest warrior… Cybernetic Ninja Spartans who’s arm cannon fires acid grenades and mini-nukes before turning into a plasma sword. In the end, it can only follow instructions. Approved and edited by BuzzFeed … Why not test them both on the gel torso to equally measure damage done. (time displacement makes the match fantastic anyway). But Rovner points out the dilemma at the heart of U.S. war strategy: “If it tries to win quickly, it might trigger nuclear war. Ep5. Memes See All. I have watched the show and they have never, ever, pointed out that they were using a game simulator. I work as a theoretical physicist for the FONAR corporation, so I have a little background in math. With a random number generator determining the outcome of these battles, one might assume fairness and objectivity; but that would be a mistake. I mean is Napoleon’s worth as a general determined by his ability to, in essence, beat up the opposing general? It doesn’t matter what kind of computer you use, what type of code processing you use or any of that. As in other RTS games, the game player serves as general over an army of semi-autonomous battle units, each possessing unique strengths, weaknesses, and methods of attack. Ivan the Terrible fought against opposing armies. You take the show seriously enough to surf around the web, find a site dedicated to it, proceed to read most if not all of the comments posted (as mine was the last one), and then–yes!–comment on it yourself. O_O… I see a brutal cycle slowly appearing wthin this blog, but I’ll ignore that for now. I too have a guilty pleasure in watching DW, mainly for the ballistics gel bodies, man that is sweet. I for one will be honored to purchase such a Program. These Tough Guys Did Martial Arts…For Health, Bruce Lee's Silent Flute Movie Explained (What Changed After His Death? I can answer that in three words: severed pig carcasses. This appears to be what is more generally known as an “Operations Research”, or for the Americans in the audience, an “Operations Analysis” simulation. Let the WWWAF.com Community battle it out and tell you who the victor would be! This Version Of Scout Without A Gun. It’s funny… but pretty idiotic.. I’ve read a lot of the posts and yea basically the winner = more armor/longer range lol. The mistake in any style v. style match is that it actually takes the humanity out of the equation. I was also ‘influentual” to both Dave Hargrave, Dave Arnseson, both creators of “simulations” Based on this data, a battle simulation program will stage a true-to-life fight to the death. To be truthful thou if spike would make sure there was a disclaimer on the show stating that the show may not show full historical technique and that it is only what their ‘experts’ know of, that is portrayed then it probably would have been fine. 5) Physical differences/attributes (as much as we martial artists would like to believe it, raw physical power makes a huge difference in combat). Yeah, it sucks that they try to make it look “scientific” and say the this is absolutely how it would turn out, but seriously anyone with a little common sense would see right through that lie. It is probably the funniest show on television. I’m sure many people will purchase or buy the program. Totally Accurate Battle Simulator is the latest game from Swedish developer Landfall and lets players build incredibly silly armies to fight it out for our amusement. Yet for over a month, your actions have left me very confused. the damage given reduced by the protection value of the “target” of said attack. They never even tried that. 3. When is GREAT BATTLES of ROME coming out? Yakuza v.s. No. According to the SpikeTV’s producers, a team of programmers spent five years developing the Deadliest Warrior simulation engine. Instead, they attempted to identify twenty different factors that could affect the outcome, and all the paths through which these factors can interact. Say you are graphing a quadratic equation. I realize they’re trying to find the toughest guys in history… but seriously? ( not a Viking fan or a Samurai hater just the facts mam), I want to see Samurai Vs Spaniard realistically simulated too see if what I suspect is true. *laugh*). The more I watch Deadliest Warrior, the sillier it seems to me. ALL these explanations are true but come one now! (Since people were throwing around credentials, I might as well mention that I have a degree in TV and radio broadcasting. Stuntmen and Actors makes Hollywood not History , This show is absolutely wonderful!! No. YES, they are pitting opponents who would likely never have fought each other. Zeus would win in a fight as he holds the power of thunder and lightning, this means that he is more powerful than all the gods, so Zeus would win in a fight. And I continually fail to see the point. Bah, I watch that show all the time. Something went wrong. I’d say that the UFC has answered the question of which martial art is the best by showing that a combination is the best route, hence, MMA. Or small errors in technique. Let’s focus on the Centurian vs. Rajput episode. Screw the simulation, they should just get the experts to fight it out…. Human beings have the capacity of if-then functions but are not restricted to them. Each warrior was trained to fight under specific parameters. In order to create a completely accurate simulator there would have to be some representation of how the brain works. In which would create a dispute against what is true and what isn’t even though everyone has a different point of perspective based on personal thoughts? amzn_assoc_region = "US"; Against the Viking, they didn’t let them try to stab through the chainmail either. There are only 187 F-22s, and the F-35 that is supposed to be joining them is running into all sorts of problems in the test phase, including the hi-tech helmet that is supposed to put all kinds of info in the pilot's visor that doesn't work right yet. Why can’t this high-tech computer simulation compute the correct results on the first try? These game rules were reworked for use on Deadliest Warrior. From what Thrand & I have been reading the samurai wasn’t accurate either for the portrayal. I’d do the same thing if someone occupied my state by military force and murdered my brothers and sisters. They do not calculate the manner in which the weapons are used; they simply calculate which ones these non professional computer programmers and medics like better. MMA only works because the rules allow it to work. Everyone should just calm down a bit. Think about it like this: a higher tier character can't always win when they're out-sped, out-haxxed, and outsmarted. I’d like to see who would win between Chuck “The Truck” Wallace and Mike McAlister. Reporting on what you care about. The calculator has know understanding of such things. The remainder is split between historical reenactment scenes, and bull sessions with their resident martial arts historians. http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0150812/ You do not need to look to the simulator to see how horrible this show is at determining what makes someone a deadly combatant. !They input the range, accuracy rate, PSI, speed, length, etc. Check them out below: (I’ll give you a hint: it wasn’t the International Ninja Council.). The Samurai won, but only had 522 kills over the Viking’s 478. As most of the previous commentators have said, there is just way too many variables involved here. Seriously, if you really want to know what it’s all about Google “OR” or “O and A”, or “Monte Carlo Simulation” and you’ll find tons of stuff. The Hardest Game Of "Who Would Win In A Fight" You'll Ever Play. Wiz: The winner is, Sans. They also do not calculate the method of use for weapons. The way that they behave in a combat situation is never the same as the next person, and one person may even have different reactions based on many variables. As for those actually interested in the thread after all this time…the methodology on the show is flawed – for one thing, in the Spartan episode, they referred to them as Bronze Age warriors, and then came them STEEL swords. Really, after seeing the gel dummy’s spine cut in half you think that could be a death blow? Select the Run Simulation button to conduct a simulated 2020 presidential election. Thor vs Batman. There's only one way to find out! http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1105343/ Each one can be from 1-100, and you want to set a fudge factor of 10% for each. Fight ends with death. Brandon, In every episode I’ve seen, there have been serious flaws in the way the “experts” think and in the simulations. However I actually commend the producers by actually having a “standard” regiment of testing and an honest attempt to use scientific methods to draw a conclusion instead of an otaku and a 300 enthusiast bitching about who’s better for an hour’s block on TV. The best way to win is with a beyond visual range kill, waaaay before a dogfight. 1 v 1 Last Man Standing; Hero Creator [beta] Voting Ep8. While, with some of their decisions I agree on, I can’t help but to feel I’m still right and they’re wrong when our opinions differ. In this episode, they tested swords; and Alexander’s Greek dagger lost because it was smaller and did not cut as deep. That does not mean it is not (remember this word because I just used one just like it) ENTERTAINING. The medic seems to be the only one with any type of experience in anything, and I love hearing when he reports the damage done. So if we associate attributes to these numbers, and have a set for each fighter, and each weapon (ending up with hundreds of data points), and they’re even close to being matched fighters, the results actually tell us nothing at all. This was almost a completely weapon based show when Ninja vs Spartan was on. Obsessed with travel? Actually, they are stone dumb. Considering that he actually works in the video game industry full time, that probably wouldn’t look too good on his resume for why his ass got canned from his previous job. In which people would either argue to the end, or until something better comes up? *laugh*) They’re thinking – “It needs to look important! I’d be more impressed by a larger margin than 8.8 percent. . I think what’s going on here is that we have an almost religious desire for science to verify history. even though the fucker rode with jim contrail and they burned the piss outta lawerence, they still stode no chance agianst al capone and the commision era mob. , I suspect the slytaren software doesnt actually share the opinions of the hosts in terms of edge factor, as can be demonstrated by the musketeers episode (armor saved the day), You could apply the same methods to UFC. No single system works as well in combat as a hybrid. How to Shoot ‘Chi’ Bolts From Your Fingertips, The Final Qigong Demonstration of John Chang, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetsuro_Shigematsu, http://shigematsu.com/tetsuro/videos/standup.wmv, http://shigematsu.com/tetsuro/videos/pop.wmv, http://shigematsu.com/tetsuro/videos/chinese.wmv, http://shigematsu.com/tetsuro/videos/Albert.wmv, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pTlkNX2eOR4, ‘Deadliest Warrior’ My Arse « The BS Historian, The Deadliest Warrior’s advanced computer simulation « All that is wrong with the world…, Spike TV’s Deadliest Warrior: Bad Science and Bad History « Notes from the Scriptorium, Deadliest Warrior – Season III | Striking Thoughts, Inside Deadliest Warrior’s Combat Simulator. Slitherine Software says that the Deadliest Warrior sim is not available for sale, but that the PC version of Great Battles of Rome will allow you to redefine troop attributes (e.g. These are the issues that create the infinite barroom talks, god love ‘um. There’s a reason they called them Bronze Age warriors. And Batman says “But within my utility belt, I’ve got a Kryptonite grenade, you’re advantage has become your downfall, hahahahaha!”. If weaponry is to be introduced into the mix, then it stands to reason that the best fighter in any match is the one who brings the best weapon, not the one with superior fighting skills. about the animals. Once blocked, a counter would easily finish off the now off-guard Rajput. This is why philosophers say “there is no truth, only power.” Power is the ability to hide an elephant in an otherwise empty room. Why is it that blogs seem to always boil down to personal attacks? Be sure Send Spike TV Deadliest Warrior and Email we Want then to admit the viking so called experts misrepresented the viking historically in the new aftermath or we are going to boycott all there product and advertisers til they do JA!!!!!! But the “this vs. that” is all Hollywood. So, any fighter vs. a fighter of the same type would result in an infinite battle? Although I think that there is a healthy skepticism being expressed at this blog, no one here has presented any meaningful understanding of combat broadly understood–and therefore why the show is complete and utter nonsense. I did not assume they should be able to compute an accurate result on the first try! A weapon “wins” in their comparison based on how effective a single strike of the weapon is, there seems to be no concern for effective reach, defensive capability, speed of attack, etc. We have an awesome name. Something for everyone interested in hair, makeup, style, and body positivity. I didn’t see the Celt vs. Persian episode, but I know the persian won…and given the shows RAMPANT 300 fetish, that is typical. It’s fantasy. fuck jesse james and spike they wouldnt ever let real mobsters get in there and show what the mob really do like. Spike TV’s Deadliest Warrior: Your Thoughts? One comment about the UFC. Slitherine Software created a real-time strategy game—The History Channel’s Great Battles of Rome—and later tweaked this game for the specific use of the Deadliest Warrior program. Because it would be his creativity (a human brain), and not the computer’s programmed rules, that create the outcome. Who would win simulator 30 Players. Can it be done better? Example: Alexander the Great and Attila the Hun. Keith brings up a real compelling argument and I’d just like to expand on it: There is a real problem in the concept of the show, because obviously you’re never going to have a true to life Ninja fight a true to life Spartan or whatever else they throw out on the show. Oh, and Mike, let your students know that if they believe everything they see on television, they are naive and lack the most common property needed for any style of fighting, and that’s common sense, a rare and precious commodity in today’s society. And when the Samurai finally ronanized they were still not terrorists. Btw CGI on the show kinda sucks. Thank you for your comment. http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1105343/. I’m sitting here, wearing my Darth Vader helmet and sucking on my retainer, trying to have a heartfelt discussion on why a Ninja would totally kick a Spartan’s a**, and I start to see responses telling me to get a grip and relax. Undertale battle simulator. PLEASE stay on your phone texting and not ruining this discussion. Would the skills relate? http://shigematsu.com/tetsuro/videos/Albert.wmv, Casey Hendershot (Viking Weapons Instructor?) As for determining the ultimate martial arts style, I actually consider that a relatively simple problem. Synopsis. ( not to be rude) that it. report. The Spartans, by and large, did NOT have steel weapons. Ep13. Come on folks, the “simulation” is indefensible and its product is completely meaningless. I still think it’s hilarious how people are taking this unsourced post seriously. They In no real way besides off handed try to say that they aren’t being totally accurate. In the final stats, it shows the Ninja’s Black Eggs as never once having been the cause of the battles end, even in 1,000 simulations. One was a thief and terrorist and the other was a wall of death. However, if Budo were to fight like Wei Shen from Sleeping Dogs, Osoro's not winning easily. 5 - 0 john Cena. My personal interests are not so much in who would beat whom, but how we might use a carefully designed simulator to improve and gain insight into our own martial arts. We know for a FACT that this is not the case. Firstly I’m not the J that posted before! We know that only one historic battle in Japan lasted more than a day, because the Japanese way of war was for everybody put all their cards on the table at the same time. and for people who just HATE jesse james he had not only a weapon advantage but a phycological one.think about it!al capone was all about fighting and didnt even think about competition.jesse james had plans of terrorizing.al capone did not. I take it your Thrands Samurai dummy from his video clips. Thanks for the post. Third, take a look again at the results for that episode. Because it dosint say in the blog. Scissors vs Rock (guest appearance by paper)! At a minimum–and I do mean minimum–this assumes that each warrior possesses equal fighting prowess with their weapons; in other words it completely ignores the idea of fighting ability.
Little River Doodles, How To Measure Oval Stove Pipe, Where Is Hosa Located, Wow Classic Decrease Magical Resistance, Miniature Glass Animals, How To Equip Bear Spear The Long Dark,
Færslur (RSS)